Here's a recent report from the PA DOC Technology Evaluation Committee (TEC) on cutdown tools. I have pictures, too, but I cannot attach them.
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
Department of Corrections
S.C.I. Retreat
June 18, 2007
Subject: Rescue Tool Test and Evaluation
To: Central Office Security Department
From: Kurt J. Girmen
Major S.C.I. Retreat
Recently I assigned Lieutenant Eustice to test and evaluate 2 (two) rescue tools. Because the current tool that we were instructed to purchase years ago by Central Office is unable to effectively cut through a large diameter items such as a rolled sheet or Restricted Housing coverall.
The first tool tested was the Benchmade “7 Hook” provide to us by Central Office Security. It has and extremely small cutting surface of less than a half inch, which severely limits the tools effective use in the Correctional setting.
The First item tested was a standard bed sheet rolled up in the diameter of a rope. This tool took approximately 22 seconds to cut through the rolled sheet, due to the small diameter of the exposed cutting surface.
The Second item tested was an authorized extension cord. The tool took approximately 1 second to cut through the cord.
The Third item tested was the standard issued coverall for our Restricted Housing Units rolled up in the diameter of a rope. The tool was unable to cut through the coverall, due to the small diameter of the exposed cutting surface.
The Fourth item test was the standard issue brown clothing shirt or trouser rolled up in the diameter of a rope. Again, the tool was unable to cut through the clothing, due to the small diameter of the exposed cutting surface.
The Second tool tested was the Smith & Wesson “SW911”. This tool has a large open blade design approximately 4 inches in length with a serrated edge.
This tools blade has a blunt tip in the shape of a standard screwdriver. The blade can be opened into a locked position.
The First item tested was an authorized extension cord. The tool took approximately 1 second to cut through the cord.
The Second item tested was a standard bed sheet rolled up in the diameter of a rope. This tool took approximately 5 seconds to cut through the rolled sheet, due to the large cutting surface and use of a sawing motion of the serrated edge.
The Third item tested was the standard issued coverall for our Restricted Housing Units rolled up in the diameter of a rope. The tool was able to cut through the coverall, in approximately 15 seconds due to the large cutting surface and the use of a sawing motion of the serrated edge.
The Fourth item test was the standard issue brown clothing shirt or trouser rolled up in the diameter of a rope. Again, the tool was able to cut through the clothing, in approximately 15 seconds due to the large cutting surface and the use of a sawing motion of the serrated edge.
However; while this tool extremely fast in cutting it would need to be handled with extreme caution because of the open blade design. There also exists the possibility of it becoming a weapon should the inmate acquire it during a faked suicide attempt. The potential risk for someone getting cut in a stressful situation also exists if the tool slips while attempting the cut down.
In conclusion it is the evaluator’s opinion that neither tool is a good choice for a Correctional setting. However; there may be other tools that possibly
could be considered that have a larger J-hook design. These tools seem to have enough cutting surface to cut larger diameter material while fairly safe to use. The hook design would allow for the cutting of the clothing from around the inmates neck area should it be necessary. One type has been located on the internet, it is as follows: The Pacific Cutlery Rescue 911 Tool which also has a lanyard. This tool was located on the Tactical Solutions Corporation web site.
If this tool is obtained we would be more than happy to evaluate this tool as well.
Attached are pictures from the evaluation of the 2 rescue tools. If there are any questions please contact me.
John S. Shaffer, Ph.D.
Executive Deputy Secretary
PA Department of Corrections
717-975-4868